articles

Slice of Heaven: Lynchburg Area Best Pizza

There's a lot of competition for best pizza in the Lynchburg area; here are some of our favorites

By Sandy Wallace February 7, 2024

Oh, pizza. How we adore you! Whether it's a busy weeknight or a lazy weekend, pizza always comes to the rescue. Plus, who can resist that heavenly combination of melted cheese, savory toppings, and a perfectly crispy crust? We certainly can't!

πŸ• Pass me another slice, please.

We are incredibly fortunate to have a number of fantastic locally-owned pizza joints right here in the Lynchburg area, ready to satisfy our every pizza craving. Join us on a mouthwatering journey through our top picks for the best pizza in and near Lynchburg.

1. 5th Street Vito's

πŸ“ Address: 522 Fifth Street, Lynchburg VA

πŸ“ž Phone: 434-426-3472

What we love: A local Macaroni KID Facebook fan says, "All fresh, handmade, great taste and quality. Great atmosphere and people. We love to support local small business. As my 6 year old grandson said, 'If it isn't Vito's, it's not REAL pizza!'"


 Artes Graficas Collective | Canva

2. Benny Scarpetta's

πŸ“ Address: 1019 Main Street, Lynchburg VA

πŸ“ž Phone: 434-528-5111

What we love: Benny's is the 'Home of the Virginia Slice' with pizza slices so big it takes two plates to hold one slice. Eat in or take out a huge 28" pizza pie!

3. La Villa Italian Restaurant

πŸ“ Address: 8109 Timberlake Road, Lynchburg, VA

πŸ“ž Phone: 434-582-4700

What we love: La Villa serves delicious pizza and so much more! La Villa offers a cash discount at the register and there's a big back room for parties, too!


 Riedelmeier | Canva

4. Waterstone Pizza

πŸ“ Address: 1309 Jefferson Street, Lynchburg, VA

πŸ“ž Phone: 434-455-1515

What we love: Waterstone Pizza serves delicious fire roasted pizza! You can also order unique salads, pastas, sandwiches, and more. The outdoor patio is perfect on warm evenings.

5. Upper Crust Pizza

πŸ“ Address: 102 Hexham Drive, Lynchburg, VA

πŸ“ž Phone: 434-237-4321

What we love: Upper Crust Pizza is conveniently located in the Wyndhurst community. Pick up a fresh slice of pizza or an entire pizza to enjoy at the outside tables or at home!

6. Graziano's Italian Restaurant

πŸ“ Address: 14805 Forest Road, Forest, VA

πŸ“ž Phone: 434-525-9510

What we love: Graziano's, located in the Forest Square Shopping Mall, offers pizza by the slice or a choice of sizes of whole pizzas. You can also order subs, salads, and a variety of entrees and desserts. 

Celebrate National Pizza Pie Day on Feb. 9 with pizza from one of these great local pizza restaurants! 

Lynchburg Macaroni Kid brings you the best of Lynchburg every day, including family-friendly events, activities, crafts, recipes, and more!

Follow us on Facebook for lots of shared local events, subscribe to our FREE weekly newsletter to be first to know what's happening around town, and check the Lynchburg Macaroni Kid website anytime to Find Your Family Fun® in Lynchburg and Central Virginia.